I realize this thread is a bit dated, however a concise explanation of these dash cluster problems and the appropriate remedy to correcting them has eluded me after months of research online. I did find plenty of people that said they could fix it, but they didn't say how. I found people that said it was a power issue (vague, but they were right). Here is what I've learned....
Ok, first of all, my dashboard cluster WAS fine in my 2003 Avalanche. About 6 months ago I took the cluster apart because most of the bulbs were blown and I didn't feel like paying GM 200-300$ for a whole new cluster, which is what they tell you is needed. The bulbs were soldered to the board, I simply unsoldered them and replaced them with 194 bulbs. This did work. However, when I reinstalled the cluster, sometimes it would work fine, sometimes it would act dead (i.e. no activity at all) except the blinkers did work and the bulbs I installed. I later went back in and replaced the bulbs with LED's since I never wanted to have to replace the bulbs again.
I checked all connects and everything seemed fine. I noticed putting pressure on connections or parts of the board sometimes made it "spring to life" and start working for a while. I thought maybe I had damaged something with the board. Then I was searching online and I found where other GM vehicle owners had experience the EXACT SAME THING but had never done anything at all with their clusters...
* Intermittent power (sometimes cluster works, sometimes not)
* Gauge works sometimes, sometimes doees not.
* Gear shift select indicator dim (or bright sometimes, dim at others despite all headlights etc. being off)
If you are experiencing anything like the above, your problem is most likely the same: There are some power resistors and diodes on the cluster board that were only soldered on at the factory "so-so". Sometimes vibration or messing around with the cluster can cause the the solder connections on these parts to weaken and only connect INTERMITTENTLY. This is a simple problem, but sometimes elusive to locate.
There are a couple of ways to test this. The first involves de-soldering the parts and testing them and reinstalling/replacing as necessary. This is the most "scientific" but there is another method that can be performed by just about anyone and it's a lot quicker and easier. This method may not find the bad soldered point all of the time but I've seen YouTube videos where people have tried it and it worked for them, and it also worked for me! What you do is take a NON-CONDUCTIVE pointed object (I used a plastic inkpen housing) and started gently pushing on various resistors and components around the board while it's hooked up to your vehicle, NOT working and vehicle ignition switch ON. In a section of the board I found several possible parts that when pressed upon made the board spring to life. One of the surface mount resistors actually fell off the board when I pushed! WOW it was barely on there. Fortunately I didn't lose it.
Solution: I fluxed and re-soldered every resistor in this area and and reinstalled in my Avalanche. For the first time in 6 months I haven't had to beat the cluster with my hand after starting the vehicle. The gauge cluster has worked FLAWLESSLY (for several weeks now at the time of this writing). I am so relieved to have found the problem and corrected it to what is actually better-than-factory condition. The soldering is better, the LED lighting is better and should last the life of the vehicle.