GM Inside News Forum banner

Consumer Report's Blog Entry On CTS

33K views 217 replies 85 participants last post by  noelvm  
#1 · (Edited)
THE STALK THAT BROKE THE CADILLAC CTS BACK

"At an early September press event at Pennsylvania's Pocono Raceway, I got my first drive the new 2008 Cadillac CTS. After about half a mile on the surrounding local roads, I remember saying to myself: "Wow, they really got it this time." The steering was spot-on, full of feedback, quick responding, linear, precise and well-weighted. The brake pedal was firm and reassuring yet easy to modulate. The model I drove had the direct-injection, 304-hp V6, which felt punchy, smooth and refined. The six-speed automatic transmission was nearly perfect. The ride was supple and controlled—even though it had the sportiest FE3 suspension. Then I felt around the rich-looking interior with the elegant stitching, stepped out and looked at the spectacular chiseled body work. That did it. I thought that I could see myself owning one of these.
Well, not anymore. The honeymoon is over."

Read on below at the link to see what upset Consumer Report's expert Gabe Shenhar so much. This blog entry by Shenhar, who is a former BMW driver instructor, has to rate as possibly the most nit picking item ever to be used as a reason not to purchase a car. The comments that follow his blog are humorous and filled with the proper derision that Shenhar's blog deserves.

The problem is that although, there are about 14-15 Consumer Report's auto testers, Shenahar writes many of the reports. One of CR's auto testers has already ribbed Shenhar over this and I guarantee you probably not another CR tester cares that much over the feature that is missing that is giving Shenhar so much consternation. But, I bet you the 'feature" that is missing will make it into the report as a low.

Here is the link. The entry is at toward the bottom of the page.

http://blogs.consumerreports.org/cars/index3.html
 
#48 ·
What else is new about CR. They always do that you know. Regardless of if they give a GM vehicle a positive review or rating I'm never going to have a good view of them. Sorry but they built a bad reputation for their selves in my mind and I'm never going to trust or like them. That's just me. ;)
 
#8 ·
You guys need to realize that the details matter, especially in the luxury car business. European buyers are used to their brand sweating everything, even things that don't seem to important to you. All the details everywhere on the car matter and leave an impression, especially when the price is high.

Even my Pontiac GTO has flash-to-pass which I use regularly.
 
#10 ·
You guys need to realize that the details matter, especially in the luxury car business. European buyers are used to their brand sweating everything, even things that don't seem to important to you. All the details everywhere on the car matter and leave an impression, especially when the price is high.

Even my Pontiac GTO has flash-to-pass which I use regularly.
Absolutely details are important, and of course I realize that. And it's espessially amplified in the luxury segment. But it's not as big of a deal that this guy is making it out to be. Details? The CTS details, plenty of them. Look at the interior, the exterior; all around there's attention to detail.
 
#9 ·
Um can't you just put the high beams on/off?
 
#11 · (Edited)
#25 ·
Ok, so I'm going to be the GMI student and wait for the teacher to answer my question...

"What the heck is flash to pass?"
http://youtube.com/watch?v=l3UAfi_QImE

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AsDyyxi9vv4&NR=1
So I'm confused. Is 'flash to pass' flashing your brights or is it to turn off the lights for a second? Each video shows a different thing.

I've done that turn off the lights thing with truckers at night before. The flashing of the brights I've only understood to mean either someone wants you to get out of the way, or I used to see it in oncoming traffic as a way to warn people that there is a cop ahead.

This feature may be missing on the CTS, but anyone one who thinks this a legitimate reason to write off the new CTS has serious bias problems. :rolleyes:
 
#14 ·
We've just heard that GM is working on fitting flash-to-pass for their HID-equipped vehicles, but the fix isn't slated to arrive until around 2010.
:blink:
I don't understand. The 9-5 has had HID and flash-to-pass for quite some time.

I thought GM cars were undergoing a reevaluation in which they were conscientiously removing the areas where parts fit and exposed screws could be seen, so parts would flow more nicely. They were also removing the "dummy plastic" fill-in parts, so it doesn't look like your car is missing a feature.

Apparently something got missed.

This day in age, flash-to-pass should be a given.
I would chalk this up to GM cost cutting.

I would be concerned that my car doesn't have that feature. Then again, I"m nitpicky.
I wouldn't buy a car that has projector headlamps with halogen foglamps. it's a very tacky look.
 
#16 ·
This day in age, flash-to-pass should be a given.
I would chalk this up to GM cost cutting.
I would chalk it up to just plain forgetting, because up until Shenhar reviewed the CTS no other reviewer mentioned it, or seemed to give a damn that it was absent.

Did Car and Driver mind? Edmunds? Road and Track? Motortrend? Dan Neill? How about any user reviews on these forums?

When GM screws up, they deserve to be criticized for it. I believe that 100%. But this is just nitpicking, pure and simple.
 
#20 ·
I could have sworn I flashed the lights on my CTS the other day.

Maybe I just flashed the high beams? I don't know but I didn't have a problem with it.

CR of course is ridiculous but thanks for the heads up.

JB
 
#26 ·
thats is absolutely right! the majority of GMI members will know because we know a thing or two about cars... but i can promise you that pretty much everyone in the united states has no clue what flash to pass is... I like Nsap have never used it nor have seen anyone else you it because simply people would just think your being an A hole... this guy is so effing full of it. please its a joke
 
#29 ·
Frankly, I think the omission of a dipstick and a temp gauge on a 3-series is a much bigger deal than this.
 
#44 ·
Actually, I think it's irresponsible of automakers to offer this. People don't know what it means... they aren't trained to use or understand 'flash-to-pass'... what if someone in their BMW pulls up behind you and flashes... you might assume they're saying "Hey, it's okay, you stay ahead of me" or "Excuse me, your gas filler door is open".

I think this flash to pass thing is actually going to cause more accidents than it will avoid... if I see soneone flash I assume it means they want me to go faster... I'll speed up just as they pull out to pass... and *CRASH* they get creamed by the semi coming in the other direction. All because they flashed to pass me. They should be concentrating on driving, as should I... not playing with silly morse-code flash signals that no one knows.

I was going to buy a 3 series, but not now! I might accidentally use flash to pass and cause or get into an accident. No thanks, I'll have to find a vehicle without this feature of death.
 
#45 ·
I've always thought "flash to pass" was hitting your brights for a second. You do this by pulling back on the stalk and then letting go. My Enclave, with HIDs, has this as did my prior CTS, also with HIDs. This makes me wonder as Shenhar even states: "Subsequently, we discovered that our Buick Enclave lacks flash-to-pass as well." Uh. I have a fully loaded Enclave and it has flash to pass. I JUST checked.

I also wonder if it's something that works with the DRL (daytime running lights) on. I know they're mandatory here, so maybe it works with the DRLs but not when DRL is off. As it's settable folks with a CTS and HIDs should try and let us know.
 
#51 ·
All I know is that every bimmer I see has large body panel gaps that no one ever notices but me; even worse than the old plastic Ion.
 
#54 ·
That and most folks don't even move over.

I recall watching a program on the CBC a number of years ago where a Canadian was commenting on how well they drove in Europe. He was waxing poetic about how drivers will move over when you flash them to the CBC reporter in the car with him somewhere in Western Europe. He then came up on a car, flashed. Flashed again. Flashed repeatedly and then began to swear. It was very funny. He then tried to regain his composure claiming he must've found the only European who was unaware that he had to move over when flashed. The CBC reporter said nothing, just smiled. It was priceless.

I find most people don't pay much attention to traffic behind them. Flashing does little, other than expend a bit of energy on behalf of the car and your fingers as you pull on the stalk.