GM Inside News Forum banner

2025 Car and Driver 10 Best Cars

7.2K views 62 replies 23 participants last post by  ChrisNJ  
#1 ·
#29 ·
On the 10 Best Trucks side of things, GM's most inexpensive new vehicle for the U.S. market scored its second win.

Image
Woohoo! 10K miles and it's been a great car the whole time. Averaging 33.6 mpg after a year, no squeaks, rattles, thumps or glitches. Still feels solid and well-built, which if we're being honest, is traditionally NOT how an entry-level GM car typically feels at any point in its life. It really is a great little wagon and not just for the price but simply because it just is.
 
#7 ·
I remember when Mustang use to be on this list all the time, now GM just dominates Detroit when it comes to on-road performance. Ford instead shifted toward off-roading performance where they dominate. GM just needs to move their EVs into performance, right now they have a long way to go but a ton of opportunity.

Naturally, plenty of critical favorites (especially from Detroit) tend to end up on the chopping block.
 
#9 ·
Good for GM!

I haven't been in an Accord in a few years, but why is it I've never stepped out of one saying "10 Best"? Maybe because I'm just a passenger and not the driver?

As far as the Cadillac's are concerned and their transition to BEV - One thing I read is the Lyriq will be substantially lowered for the V. If true I take that as an omen that GM is willing to make big changes to make their BEV's worthy of the V badge....
 
#10 ·
I haven't been in an Accord in a few years, but why is it I've never stepped out of one saying "10 Best"? Maybe because I'm just a passenger and not the driver?
That might be it. :D

All joking aside, the current gen Honda Accord is a fine car for passengers, but an even better car for the driver. It remains the benchmark for midsized sedans. As Mr. Dorian from C&D put it:

Image
 
#16 ·
And out of that list, probably only half the models make money, LOL.
 
#17 ·
Nine of the ten are probably at least break even. But the tenth model incurred a loss of nearly $427,000 per vehicle in Q3 2024 (1,805 units produced with operating loss of $0.77 billion that quarter):

Image
 
#28 ·
^^^
And the Malibu made the list around 2009 I think. But even then, they only add an additional midsize car to their list. The Accord's place seems permanent. I don't think it's always been deserving.

There's been GM cars that make an appearance for one, maybe two years (Cadillac STS years ago, for one). Then they disappear. But Accords, even without significant updates between generations, are always there year after year, even over newer midsize models.

There's always been some odd choices. The Honda Fit was a perennial as well. And I suppose it was there because of their desire to include difference type of vehicles on the list, not just a bunch of high-dollar, luxury or performance cars. But the Fit? Nothing wrong with it, but c'mon!
 
  • Helpful
Reactions: 1958carnut
#32 ·
But the Fit? Nothing wrong with it, but c'mon!
Honda Fit's C&D 10 Best honors in past years had the same rationale as that for Chevy Trax currently: both products are "better than expected, and better than it needs to be".