The GT does look pretty good. The base model, which I have seen on the road, looks crappy in my opinion.The Vibe GT is freaking gorgeous. Honestly. What a beautiful car for this segment.
The others are downright awful. Hubcaps? Even if they aren't, they sure as hell look like them, and if it walks like a duck, talks like a duck...
I can see the GT appealing to younger buyers...the Scion crowd.