GM Inside News Forum banner
1 - 20 of 96 Posts

· Super Moderator
Joined
·
23,056 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Former Federal Officials Warn Ditching This Old-Timey Car Feature Might Be Disastrous In Emergencies (msn.com)
Story by Peter Corn

February 28, 2023

Pete Buttigieg’s inbox is getting blown up by former emergency officials warning the Secretary of Transportation that removing AM radios from cars could be disastrous in the event of an emergency. In case you haven’t heard, automakers are talking about taking AM radio out of new cars moving forward. This could be a problem.

What are AM radios for?
Many new cars, especially EVs, have already been phasing out the old-timey car feature for the last decade or so. AM radio removal has mostly been contained to European carmakers. According to The Drive, as of last summer, the makers ditching AM cite sound quality issues as the main reason for the deletion.

AM radio is a simpler, earlier form of radio transmission. This type of radio is often called medium-wave radio. The people worried about the loss of AM aren’t just wanting to conserve it for no reason. The benefits of AM are that not only can AM signals be sent much further than FM, but nearly 90 percent of the country can still be reached via AM.

However, it’s happening in America, too. The 2023 Ford F-150 Lightning just axed its AM receiver.

A letter from seven former Federal Emergency Management Agency administrators was sent warning Secretary Pete about losing AM. “Should this continue, it will represent a grave threat to future local, state, and federal disaster response and relief efforts,” the letter warns.

“When all else fails, radio stations are often the last line of communications that communities have,” added Craig Fugate, head of FEMA under President Obama and one of the letter’s signatories.

“AM radio has been tested over and over during the most devastating natural disasters—and has withstood them all,” added Antwane Johnson, a current FEMA official.

Continues at link
 

· Super Moderator
Joined
·
23,056 Posts
Discussion Starter · #2 ·
Wow, I had no idea some manufacturers have deleted AM radio, I no longer regularly listen, but view AM radio as something with a decent amount of content and presumably followers.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,874 Posts
But .... the Pony Express, we must save the Pony Express!
It is actually worse that you imply. If we had saved the Pony Express, then the rider could yell an emergency message as he and his steady steed speed down the road. However, having an AM radio in your car does you no good unless your radio is tuned to an AM station. I am most certainly a boomer, and my Malibu includes AM radio. However, my radio also includes FM and SiriusXM. My radio is tuned to SiriusXM most of the time. At other times, it is tuned to FM. My radio is never tuned to AM. For the younger set, they are most likely listening to music on their phones, USB drives, or some other source.

The solution is not to force auto manufacturers to retain AM radio receivers. The solution include sound systems that can be interrupted to receive emergency information.
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
38,048 Posts
That's all I listen to. Guess I'm not sofistiekayted enough for modern lektrik Fords. Oh vell. I will schtruggle on.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
45,613 Posts
Well... the only time I listen to AM radio is during baseball season — KNBR 680 in the Bay Area.
Do I really need it? No. I have the MLB App and can stream the baseball games. And I have the KNBR app should I want to listen to the sports pundits about why the Giants/Niners/Warriors/Sharks suck/don't suck this season.

I keep an AM/FM radio at home in case of emergencies, which can happen during major earthquakes, etc. And I've got spare batteries.

I can live without AM in the car.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,048 Posts
The problem is that AM radio dial has been reduced to a cultural desert. Apart from baseball games, there's little there worth tuning into. The inherent low quality of AM makes it undesirable for music, and mostly all that can be found on the AM dial these days are right wing screamers and televangelists, neither of which I would ever listen to intentionally.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,591 Posts
No alerts going to my phone- not a single one in the last 4 years.

I'm 70% on XM and 25% on CarPlay. 5% : occasionally roll thru the presets on AM/FM. Used to listen to baseball on AM quite a bit in the evenings; that peaked about 25 years ago and dwindled to 0 the last couple of years.

My question is; what are automakers 'saving' by eliminating AM reception, exactly... as far as hardware is concerned?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
945 Posts
The advantage AM has is being able to reach long distances. Messages, instructions, information could be received in areas where all local infrastructure is out. In Mississippi, after Katrina there was nothing. No local radio, no electricity, no internet, no cell phones, nothing. What hadn't been knocked down by the winds had been flooded by the storm surge. For two weeks the only communication in or out was by amateur radio operators. They were able to use HF to communicate outside of the area and VHF, UHF to communicate in the area. It was two weeks before the first portable cell phone system (semi trailer) was set up. Being mobile, some vehicles are able to survive things like Katrina, they can receive news via AM radio. Sure, there would be issues with fossil fuels or electricity to keep vehicles moving but the radios would still work for longer periods of time.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
9,675 Posts
Don't emergency alerts go through our cellphones now? I get silver alerts, amber alerts, weather alerts....all through my phone.
Keeping A.M. for emergency alerts is b.s. What better time to use it than on 9-11 or during hurricanes. It was never used effectively in any area I have heard of so it’s pretty pointless with everyone having phones now.
 

· Registered
What's new and upcoming...
Joined
·
15,948 Posts
The problem is that AM radio dial has been reduced to a cultural desert. Apart from baseball games, there's little there worth tuning into. The inherent low quality of AM makes it undesirable for music, and mostly all that can be found on the AM dial these days are right wing screamers and televangelists, neither of which I would ever listen to intentionally.
Yeah now that Rush Limbaugh is gone, what's the point. :(
 

· Premium Member
Joined
·
38,048 Posts
The problem not is the cost savings of removing an AM Tuner, it’s the cost of shielding the AM Tuner from all the electronic hash generated by these vehicles.
Aluminum foil is cheap.
Yeah now that Rush Limbaugh is gone, what's the point. :(
Plante and Howie are still cookin. And I can't find an oldies rock n roll station anywhere on my FM dial. What is the world coming to?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,007 Posts
No alerts going to my phone- not a single one in the last 4 years.

I'm 70% on XM and 25% on CarPlay. 5% : occasionally roll thru the presets on AM/FM. Used to listen to baseball on AM quite a bit in the evenings; that peaked about 25 years ago and dwindled to 0 the last couple of years.

My question is; what are automakers 'saving' by eliminating AM reception, exactly... as far as hardware is concerned?
I wonder if it's a regional thing or a carrier thing?
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,007 Posts
Keeping A.M. for emergency alerts is b.s. What better time to use it than on 9-11 or during hurricanes. It was never used effectively in any area I have heard of so it’s pretty pointless with everyone having phones now.
Feels like something not wanting to fade away, but I can't imagine the percentage of AM users is very high. Maybe it's time to go the way of the cassette deck?
 
1 - 20 of 96 Posts
Top