View Single Post
Old 03-22-2008, 03:15 PM   #11 (permalink)
DuSpinnst
Banned
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Unemployment Hell
Drives: '08 Corvette '08 Grand Cherokee
Posts: 17,587
Re: LA TIMES: BMW 1-series can fly; too bad it's heavy and ugly

Quote:
Originally Posted by goblue View Post
Actually - I think he called it dead on. I could do without the hyperbole and cliches, but basically the 1 series is a slightly smaller, just as expensive, slightly faster, and much less attractive version of the 3 series - without its fantastic hardtop convertible. Thats how he called it - couldn't agree more.

BMW had real opportunity here. Use that fantastic motor in a lighter, tighter vehicle, and they could have built a refined, comfortable lotus. Instead we get a 3 series that spent a few seconds in a car crusher.

Thats what Neil is getting at - lost opportunity, and its refreshing to see that vitriol aimed at something not wearing a domestic badge.
I think it looks fine, and he can't write anything without trying to be "intellectually funny."
DuSpinnst is offline   Reply With Quote